Condo Craze and HOAs
Advertise with us →
Menu ☰
← Florida condo & HOA blog

The Brooklyn building collapse and Florida condo owners’ repair questions

Greg Batista examines the Brooklyn building collapse. Florida condo and HOA callers ask about sidewalk hazards, balcony repairs, board elections and reserves.

The Brooklyn building collapse and Florida condo owners’ repair questions

What could a photograph and an excavation plan tell investigators about the Brooklyn building collapse? On the November 15 edition of Condo Craze and HOAs, structural engineer Greg Batista walked Eric Glazer and Karen Curtis through both. Florida owners then called about a sidewalk the board had been warned about, tile in the path of a balcony repair, and how their associations handle elections and reserves.

The Brooklyn collapse

03:05 · What was known about the building — Eric Glazer and Karen Curtis opened with the collapse of a three-story rental building in Flatbush, Brooklyn. They discussed reports about the building before the collapse and the excavation next door. The cause and responsibility were still under investigation.

14:51 · Greg Batista examines the site — Structural engineer Greg Batista compared an earlier image of the property with an excavation plan. He pointed out where the plan showed temporary supports and explained the limits of vibration monitoring. When Eric asked whether the plan was deficient, Batista said he didn’t have enough information to draw that conclusion.

Earlier aerial view of the Flatbush block, with the three-story building beside a lower building outlined in red.

Batista began with an earlier view of the block and marked the building he was discussing. View in the broadcast.

Exterior wall with a vertical crack outlined in yellow and a red arrow pointing to it.

In his second image, Batista drew attention to a crack visible on the exterior wall. View in the broadcast.

Excavation after the collapse, with temporary supports marked in yellow and the former building footprint outlined in red.

Batista used this view to identify the excavation and the temporary supports visible along one edge. View in the broadcast.

Excavation plan with shoring marked in yellow and the neighboring apartment building outlined in red.

On the annotated plan, Batista traced the proposed supports. He said he could not determine fault from the drawing. View in the broadcast.

Questions from condo and HOA owners

30:41 · A sidewalk hazard reported to the board — An HOA owner had photographed uneven sidewalk sections and wanted to know what happened after the board received the pictures. The conversation turned to how the board documented the warning and what its insurance paperwork said.

37:33 · Who pays for tile disturbed by balcony work? — A caller asked who would replace interior tile if balcony repairs extended into a condo. Eric distinguished the repair itself from damage to a unit and discussed how the declaration and the contractor’s work could affect the answer.

45:13 · An election dispute still in arbitration — An HOA director asked how the board could conduct business while the previous election was being challenged. Eric asked whether the challenge was an election dispute or a recall, then discussed what the next annual election could mean for the pending case.

53:29 · What if the board can’t fill its seats? — A caller asked who would run the association if newly elected directors missed their certification deadline. Eric discussed what happens if the directors later get certified and what a court-appointed receiver could cost the community.

56:25 · Which reserves was the caller asking about? — A condo owner said the structural reserves were funded and asked about voting on other reserves. Eric separated the two parts of the budget, using the pool, elevators and carpeting as examples from their conversation.

59:15 · Shared management and screening fees — The same caller described a proposal for one company to manage several separately governed associations. She also asked about fees for background checks. Eric explained why he couldn’t answer the fee question without seeing the governing documents.

An owner’s representative on the job

1:03:14 · Who represents the owners during construction? — The final guest described the owner’s representative as the person watching a project on the association’s behalf, separate from the engineer and contractor. He returned to the Brooklyn discussion to explain the value of a second pair of eyes.

1:08:14 · A brief mention of Logan Circle — At sign-off, the hosts briefly mentioned a shooting in Washington, D.C.’s Logan Circle. The Brooklyn collapse was the focus of this episode’s reporting.

Watch the full November 15 broadcast on YouTube.

Now playing
Condo Craze and HOAs

On demand · Episode guide

Condo Craze and HOAs episode

Select an episode to see its description.

Open on YouTube

Common-area TV guide

Jump to a chapter

Choose a topic to start there

Chapter markers will appear here when they are provided for this episode.